Saturday, February 23, 2013

The Loneliest Twin in History?

          It is commonly thought that identical twins share the same personalities and preferences in addition to their exterior appearances.  However, due to epigenetic inheritance--genetic makeup regardless of chromosome content-- and surrounding environments, identical siblings can develop their distinct traits and styles.

          This is definitely true of Sarah Vowell and her twin sister, Amy Vowell, who display vastly different personalitites in the former's piece "Shooting Dad". In the essay, Sarah Vowell communicates her disgust of guns and her father's love of them. This proves highly irregular, as her father has crafted weapons her whole life, and her twin sister adores the family tradition of learning about gun use and warfare.

          When Sarah recounts first shooting a gun, she remembers "the sound it made was as big as God...like a foe; it hurt" (Paragraph 11, 4-5). Interestingly enough, when Sarah matures and attempts to understand her father's joy in guns, she admits feeling "giddiness when the cannon shot off" (Paragraph 24, 1-2). Therefore, it is shown that the narrator doesn't despise weapons as much as she thought. She defines herself as an artist, a music enthusiast, which allows her to finally appreciate the deafening sound produced from the release of a trigger.

          The final impression of Sarah Vowell leaves the reader thinking she is very similar to her father and her sister. In this way, Amy Vowell --portrayed as the "loneliest twin in history"--only had to suffer from this paradoxical affliction until her sister was ready to accept the glory of firing guns. Perhaps identical twins who possess different characteristics are more alike than even they themselves deem; it takes time for separate individuals to acquire similar interests and passions.

3 comments:

  1. That's a good point, Sarah turned out to be a lot like her sister, just like she was her dad, because of her acceptance of her family's gun habit.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I see some AP Bio coming into this :D I like the way you explain that twins do not necessarily have to share similar interests. I also like the quotes you used and the ending statement; maybe, like Vowell and her father, the twins are overlooking what makes them alike.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Nice analysis of the "Shooting Dad" piece! I like how you pointed out the connection between Vowell's interest in music and her eventual appreciation of the sound of the gun shot. Also I like how you took a different point of view and looked at the similarities/differences between the twin sister and Vowell. Cool post! :)

    ReplyDelete

Please comment!